A storys setting is usually described in the beginning of the story, giving an explanation of where and when the story is taking place. To jingmeis mother, america is the land of opportunity. E i had knew thoughts, will fuel thoughts or rather thoughts filled with lots of wonts tan 511. Do you think that firstgeneration children of immigrants have it harder than their parents. Title the short story two kinds, written by amy tan, focuses on the struggles of a young protagonist named jingmei trying to find herself without the influences and pressure of others.
The short story setting is in china, and the narrative is part of the novel the joy luck club. Amy tans story, two kinds, works independently or as part of her novel, the joy luck club. How would you describe the tone of the opening paragraph. Jingmei, a victim of her own undoing in amy tans two kinds. Born in the us to immigrant parents from china, amy tan failed her mothers expectations that she become a doctor and concert pianist. Amy tan s story, two kinds, works independently or as part of her novel, the joy luck club. These kinds of explanations made me feel my mother and i spoke two. She has high hopes that her daughter will be a great success as a prodigy. How would you describe the overall tone of two kinds.
In the story, two kinds, amy tan writes about a relationship between a mother and a daughter. Here, we discuss the setting of the short story two kinds by amy tan. Because of her mothers constant pressure for her to play music, jingmeis desire to be a normal chineseamerican girl turns into a search for her own identity and a struggle between her and her mother. The magic of the first part of the story comes largely from ms. Several of the stories appeared in periodicals separately, many of them in atlantic monthly, which. Background two kinds is a story in amy tans immensely successful first book, the joy luck club. In my analysis of two kinds, a portion of tan s larger work, the joy luck club, i look at how the emphasis on the american dream in jingmei woos life hinders her identity development and ultimately causes her to be. The short story outlines the main character jingmei june woos childhood and the effects of her mothers high expectations for her life. Of course you can be prodigy, too, my mother told me when. The short story outlines the main jing mei woos childhood and the effects of. This was a time where everyone hunted for success, especially for the mother in this story. The short story outlines the main character jingmei.
Discussion of themes and motifs in amy tans two kinds. Tans rich language, sense of humor and comic images. Two kinds of characters two kinds, a short story by amy tan, opens with jingmei june woo, the narrator, reflecting on her mothers life after shes dead. Two kinds amy tan my mother believed you could be anything you wanted to be in america. The plot of the story is about a mother and her daughter. Amy tan s story two kinds has several levels of content. Sep 09, 20 two kinds by amy tan posted on september 9, 20 by lorena two kinds talks about the conflict jingmeiwho is also the narratorand her mother had when they first came to america in 1949. Tan intended the book to be read as a loose collection of interrelated stories, but it is. In two kinds by amy tan we have the theme of hope, identity, rebellion, responsibility, blame, independence and acceptance. These two kinds of daughters match up with the two songs because one song says perfect which is obedience and the other song is pleading child which about a child who follows a mind of their own. Two kinds is a chapter from tans book, the joy luck club, which is made up of sixteen stories about tan growing up in america with a mother from ancient chinese customs tan, 189.
The short story two kinds by amy tan is structured around the wish of a chinese mother for her child to become a prodigy. Clair the twentysix malignant gates o rules of the game. Two kinds is an excerpt from her first book, the joy luck club, which received high acclaim. Woo tries to mold her daughter into a child actress, but. About the author was born in 1952 an american writer explore motherdaughterrelationships the chineseamerican experience bestknown work is thejoyluckclub a movie adapted by. Teaching two kinds by amy tan connected teaching and.
Amy tans two kinds is a short story about the relationship between a chineseamerican mother and her american daughter. Find out what kinds they are, and how this view affects a motherdaughter relationship in an excerpt from amy tans novel the joy luck club. The authors mother was looking for a talent in her daughter which she didnt find and jingmei was getting frustrated and she ended up rebelling against her mother. Tans popular stories are informed by her chineseamerican heritage as they explore family ties and understanding, memory and inheritance, generational tensions and conflicting cultures. What happens at the end of the story two kinds by amy tan. In this paper i put a critical reflection on a symbolic crisis of identity found in amy tans two kinds in which the narrator, jingmei narrates her conflict. Jan 26, 2016 the short story two kinds is written by amy tan. Jingmei, the womans daughter, proves to be a mediocre child and disappoint. Literary analysis there are many key elements which together make up a story, namely a storys setting, its main characters, the plot, and the symbolism it contains. Two kinds summary two kinds is a short story by amy tan that presents the conflict between a girl, june, and her mother, suyuan.
You could work for the government and get good retirement. A mistakable understanding of a child prodigy in amy tans two k. What insight into jingmeis mothers faith in america does the third paragraph provide. Joy luck club was adapted into a feature film in 1994, for which amy tan was a. Title the short story two kinds, written by amy tan, focuses on the struggles of a young protagonist named jingmei trying to find herself without the influences and pressure of.
Analysis of two kinds by amy tan 1425 words 6 pages. Find out what kinds they are, and how this view affects a motherdaughter relationship in an excerpt from amy tan s novel the joy luck club. As an immigrant myself i understand the struggle the transition they had to experience and how they had to manage with what the country has to offer. Her mother lost everyone and everything back in china, and she came to america in 1949 with big hopes and many dreams america was where all my mothers hopes lay 471. Two kinds by amy tan symbol in amy tans short story two kinds, jingmei is an american born daughter who had a mother who wanted her daughter to become a child prodigy. Mar 31, 2008 this is an extract from the short story two kinds written by amy tan. Explanatory text explain how tan uses the central conflict between mother and daughter to develop the theme of the work.
Two kinds talks about the conflict jingmeiwho is also the narratorand her mother had when they first came to america in 1949. Do you think, as a reader, that jingmeis mother was being cruel in how she pushed her daughter. About the author was born in 1952 an american writer explore motherdaughterrelationships the chineseamerican experience bestknown work is thejoyluckclub a movie adapted by the book was made. This activity was created by a quia web subscriber. How does it suggest that the reader should interpret the second paragraph.
She doesnt speak out as an analyzer to illustrate what is the real problem between her and her mother. The joy luck club two kinds by amy tan, pages 142144. Two kinds by amy tan 9 september 2016 the story takes place around 1960s, where the narrator talks about her childhood and 1980s towards the end when she had grown up to be an adult about thirty years old. Of course, you can be a prodigy, too, my mother told me when i was nine. Tan intended the book to be read as a loose collection of interrelated stories, but it is often referred to as a novel. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Explain the significance of the title of the story two. We didnt immediately pick the right kind of prodigy. Jan 26, 2016 today in class we read and discussed a short story by amy tan titled two kinds. Essay on two kinds type your essay on two kinds below. Amy tan this study guide consists of approximately 38 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of two kinds. It is about the relationship of a girl the narrator and her mother. Two kinds she has high hopes that her daughter will be a great success as a prodigy.
Further reading two kinds is the last story in the second of four sections of amy tans immensely successful first book, the joy luck club. As a vignette, or standalone story, it serves as an illustration of two important themes, or main. Tan intended the book to be read as a loose collection. Multicultural story, two kinds amy tanjhedit authorstream. Essay amy tan s two kinds two kinds by amy tan is a story of a nineyearsold girl by name jingmei, who was from an immigrant family from china. Two kinds by amy tan my mother believed you could be anything you wanted to be in america. The time setting of the short story can be deduced from the clues that jingmei offers about her mother. Analysis of two kinds by amy tan in the story two kinds, the author, amy tan, intends to make reader think of the meaning behind the story. The conflict became so bitter and lasted so long because she started to rebel against her mothers will by. How do you think your own upbringing affected your answer. The story takes place in san franciscos china town. In tan s two kinds, identify specific character traits of jing mei. In two kinds by amy tan, the child jingmei feels that she must rebel against her mothers wishes to be true to herself. This story is actually an episode from tans first novel the joy luck club 1989, which many of you may have seen in its film version.
Two kinds is a short story from the book the joy luck club by amy tan. The joy luck club by amy tan acknowledgments the joy luck club eforeward feathers from a thousand li away o the joy luck club. Two kinds by amy tan international english by sandra. Narrated in the first person by a woman called jingmei woo the story is a memory piece and after reading the story the reader realises that tan may be exploring the theme of hope. In this lesson, students begin their exploration of two kinds, the second chapter long excerpt from.
Here are all the word lists to support the reading of grade 10. Shes not precisely sure where her daughters talents lie, but she is sure that her daughter possesses great ability it is simply a matter of finding the right avenue for jingmeis talents. Author introduction two kinds by amy tan amy tan is an american born chinese that grew up in the san francisco bay area. Today in class we read and discussed a short story by amy tan titled two kinds. Just like many short stories, two kinds is comprised of five traditional plot elements. It is clear that some of the events in the short story reflect events that happened in the authors. Oct 11, 2017 in two kinds by amy tan we have the theme of hope, identity, rebellion, responsibility, blame, independence and acceptance. The issue of conflicting personalities in amy tans story two kinds 1,1 words. Two kinds is a short story from amy tans book the joy luck club. Teaching two kinds by amy tan connected teaching and learning. Jingmei, the womans daughter, proves to be a mediocre child and disappoints her mother. Tan writes about two songs played by jingmei, perfectly contented and pleading child. The mother of jingmei wants her daughter to become famous, but jingmei just wants to be herself.
Amy tan is a writer that focuses and writes a lot about motherchild relationships. Two kinds talks about a motherdaughter relationship and the struggles that immigrant families have when they arrive in america. In the story two kinds, jingmeis mother believes that children in america can achieve anything they desire. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. The short story two kinds was written by amy tan the daughter of chinese immigrants who was born in oakland and raised in california. Primarily, it is a struggle between a mother and daughter. Two kinds is a short story that was initially published in what periodical in february 1989. Tans first novel, the joy luck club, drew on her troubled relationship with her mother, who was born in china. Doc literary analysis of two kinds by amy tan victoria. They are of chinese origin, and the mother has emigrated to america some years ago with her husband. She immigrated from china to america because of the chance of success.
237 990 150 817 337 1593 109 1358 1101 915 1580 993 421 1470 264 432 377 1386 531 1414 1386 950 1229 49 909 418 920 577 42 697 317 1383 1324 1097 991 229 1397 403 906 957 212 1137 1112